What the NXIVM Cult Teaches Us About Coercive Control, Belonging, and How Smart People Get Trapped

You know those stories you hear and think, “That could never be me”?
Yeah. That’s what makes them dangerous.

The NXIVM cult didn’t recruit lost souls in white robes. It pulled in high-achievers...people who were hungry for purpose, growth, and belonging. It was a masterclass in coercive control disguised as personal development. And the story of Sarah Edmondson, one of NXIVM’s most prominent whistleblowers and the woman who helped bring it down, shows exactly how that happens—and how to protect yourself from it.

How Cults (and “Cultish” Systems) Hook Smart People

Coercive control isn't always so obvious. It can often start out looking like “community.”

It looks like a clear path to your potential. A leader who “gets you.” A group that finally sees your brilliance.

That’s what NXIVM promised. It sold empowerment. What people got was hierarchy, manipulation, and a system that punished questioning.

But if you strip away the branding and scandal, this pattern happens everywhere—corporate cultures, social movements, influencer followings, even friend groups. The tactics are the same:

• Love bombing (“You belong here. You’re special.”)

• Isolation (“People outside won’t understand.”)

• Language loops (“If you question it, you’re resisting growth.”)

• Fear of exclusion (“Don’t ruin what we’ve built.”)

Sound familiar? That’s why Sarah’s story isn’t just about a cult. It’s about the quiet ways we hand over power every day.

3 Red Flags of Coercive Control You Might Be Missing

1. When “empowerment” depends on someone else’s approval.
Any system that makes you prove your worth, loyalty, or readiness before you’re accepted is not empowerment—it’s conditioning.

2. When transparency costs you.
If you have to hand over secrets, money, or personal shame to earn belonging (what NXIVM called “collateral”), that’s coercion, not connection.

3. When language starts replacing logic.
Watch for buzzwords that make you doubt your instincts—“trust the process,” “you’re resisting,” “this is just your ego.” Those phrases were NXIVM’s favorite tools to shut down critical thinking.

What Freedom Actually Looks Like

Sarah Edmondson calls her recovery “rebuilding trust in my own brain.”
That’s the work:

• Learning to trust your gut again.

• Getting curious about why belonging mattered so much.

• Noticing where you outsource validation and calling it back.

Freedom isn’t about rejecting every system. It’s about knowing when a system stops serving you.

Your Mini Self-Audit for Belonging vs. Control

Ask yourself:

• Does this group encourage questions, or avoid them?

• Do I feel expanded or smaller after interacting with it?

• Is my value earned, or inherent?

If you start to feel foggy, afraid, or constantly “not enough,” pay attention. That’s your signal. You don’t need to be in a cult to experience coercive control—you just need to be human in a world that’s really good at selling certainty.

Listen to the Full Episode

Sarah Edmondson joined me on Reinvention Room to share what really happened inside NXIVM—the rise, the unraveling, and the lessons we can all use to reclaim our own agency.

🎧 Listen to Part 1: “Inside the Notorious NXIVM Cult: Sarah Edmondson’s Story” — available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen.

If you’ve ever questioned your belonging, your intuition, or the systems you put your faith in—this one’s for you.

Listen Now: The Reinvention Room Podcast

Watch Now: Reinvention Room on YouTube

If you’ve got a podcast or an idea that won’t leave you alone, here's your sign to take it seriously. Not just because it's fun (it is), but because it can change how people see you, connect with you, and trust you. That's the magic.

And if you're wondering how to make it actually work? Book a free clarity call with me at allisonhare.com/freecall. I'll help you turn that idea into a tight, bingeable, client-attracting machine.